Ardorgold’s View of the Golden Retriever

For many years, Ardorgold, including in its former incarnations as Gilded Peak and JenLore, has placed a high value on the level of retrieving desire in our breeding stock.

When we purchased Rachel’s Fanfare for Columbo in 1994, we were seduced by Fanfare’s overall substance and conformation, meaning conformation to the written Breed Standard for the American Golden Retriever, as promulgated by AKC, but we especially liked pedigrees balanced with conformation-bred and field-bred overachievers, i.e. showring champions and those achieving titles in Field Trialing and other events.

Fanfare’s pedigree had an equal number of Golden types, having a conformation champion and Junior Hunter sire and a field-bred dam.  He was a beautiful prepotent package.

After all, the Golden was developed by an Edwardian aristocrat and hunting man who tramped the Scottish moors of his estate Guisachan, who had the money and leisure to cross several different breeds, one misty morning witnessing the birth of two yellow puppies, which he bred to each other, then outcrossing to field spaniels and back into his “yellow” line.  There is no question that while he was enamored of the golden color of his dogs, he was concerned with how readily they brought him game birds to hand, that their coats repelled water, that their powerful noses could track a bird’s point of landing as it died, that their physiques lent themselves to moving swiftly and easily over and through bramble and bracken and heather.

As time went on The Golden Retriever Club of Great Britain and the UK, headquartered in Scotland before England, began breeding for “construction”– the “correct” build and look of the dog, writing down a bible of sorts, The Kennel Club British Breed Standard, for everything from the head to the tail.  And also over time, when British Goldens, falling into American parlance as English Goldens, were imported into the U.S. to cross with our early bloodlines, the American Kennel Club was formed for the purposes of pitting one dog against the other in conformation shows.

Earlier, long before the formation of the American Kennel Club, a movement arose among gundog enthusiasts of all breeds in this country that placed nearly total emphasis on the qualities that had delighted Lord Tweedmouth as he cut into a roast partridge and quaffed a glass of French white.  The group drew up a charter and started a magazine they named American Field.  Then, they founded a registry, The Field Dog Stud Book, which before there were online databases, involved the maintenance of meticulously kept “stud books,” where the names of breed inviduals and their progeny and grand–progeny were annotated and preserved.

Today, as has been “trending” for the past decade, most “English Cream” breeders purchase cream-coated British Golden Retrievers bred for the UK showring.  But whereas in America, the breed has fallen into two distinct types of conformation dogs with flowing coats and a ton of “bone,” and “field-bred” Goldens generally dark red and long-legged and smaller than their ring-bred kin–in Europe and other parts of the world where the KC Breed Standard governs most breeding, retrieving desire is as important as how the dog looks.  Many breeders test their dogs in the field before taking him  into the ring.

We believe that while the British cream-coated Golden Retriever is breathtakingly beautiful, retrieving desire must be present and evident in our breeding stock–that a given breed should be purpose-bred with an eye to its construction/conformation, not the other way around.

We have determined that in registering our foreign dogs with an American registry, a purpose-oriented registry is preferable.  As you can see in reading about the FDSB on our home page and this one, this registry is two million dogs strong with an excellent reputation.  Seldom does an English Cream breeder register FDSB; it doesn’t occur to the novice breeders who are buying up cream-coated dogs in droves in knowing next to nothing about the breed.

Additionally, AKC is so threatened by the American public’s fascination with these dogs that it has launched a smear campaign through the Golden Retriever Club of America, pretending to debunk the “myths” of longevity and lower incidence of cancer of the English Golden.  It bashes breeders who use the phrase English Cream as if such dogs are a separate breed, and it warns all comers to its website that if a breeder has not posted the results of genetic testing at, that breeder should be avoided like the plague.

Please think about these ploys for your business and the AKC agenda. In our view there is but one reason to register one’s Golden Retriever with AKC– to participate in conformation shows, which FDSB does not believe in and does not consider to be true tests of the merits of an individual dog.  Now the American public thinks that to have an AKC dog is prestigious and the only legitimate registry–thanks as noted, to AKC propaganda.

FDSB doesn’t proclaim its existence to the world or say to anyone that its way is the only way.  Moreover, once you register your Ardorgold puppy with FDSB, you can easily register with AKC or the United Kennel Club.  These three registries recognize each other and co-exist. But AKC’s fall into disgrace among serious British type fanciers is repugnant to us as well.

For this reason we will supply you with an FDSB puppy registration; when you get permanent FDSB papers, you can register your dog with the AKC if you so desire.